With Clarity vs. Brilliance

With Clarity vs. Brilliance

You have plenty of options when buying fine jewelry. Two well-known fine jewelry companies are Brilliance and With Clarity. We compared the two companies and With Clarity has some benefits that you really should consider. Keep reading to learn more about the two companies.

Cost and Transparency

Cost is top of mind when browsing companies for fine jewelry. Most companies tell you they have the best prices, but you won’t know until you compare. Both Brilliance and With Clarity have robust search options for loose diamonds so you can dial in the quality (4 Cs) and select the perfect diamond.

It’s also helpful that With Clarity is transparent on how they obtain incredible prices. With Clarity aims to make shopping for diamonds simple and affordable. They vet each step in the process so you can shop confidently and get affordable prices by going straight to the diamond source. With Clarity works with trusted diamond cutters who use ethical practices to source and shape With Clarity diamonds. Certification is also important. Both lab grown and natural earth-mined diamonds come with a GIA or IGI certification depending and an inspection by their in-house team of gemologists.

Here’s a comparison of the lowest cost 1 carat round lab diamond on each site.

1 CT. Lab Grown 1.5 CT. Lab Grown 2 CT. Lab Grown 2.5 CT. Lab Grown 3 CT. Lab Grown 3.5 CT. Lab Grown
With Clarity Starting at $562 Starting at $992 Starting at $1,690 Starting at $2,448 Starting at $2,686 Starting at $4,001
Brilliance Starting at $696 Starting at $1,092 Starting at $1,734 Starting at $2,619 Starting at $3,259 Starting at $6,001

Shop Lab Diamonds

Love Custom Rings?

With Clarity specializes in custom jewelry and rings while Brilliance.com does not have a custom offering. You can contact With Clarity with your rough or detailed custom ring idea and get a quote back within a day including the pricing info. Their team of gemologists and design consultants works in-house in NYC to make all the custom designs.

As part of creating custom rings, With Clarity’s Home Preview program allows you to try on up to two custom replica rings from home. It bridges the gap between online and in-person shopping by allowing you to try on jewelry at home using replica rings. You receive two rings to try on for three days. These replica rings look exactly like “real” With Clarity engagement rings, and are made of a white metallic alloy and round one carat diamond simulant. When you’re done, you mail the rings back. Sometimes it helps to see your creation in person so that you can find your perfect ring.

Customer Service You Can Count On

Purchasing fine jewelry requires accessible customer service. With Clarity has an A+ rating with the BBB and Brilliance.com isn’t accredited by the BBB and has a C- rating. Part of the reason With Clarity has a high rating is their willingness to help their customers and get questions answered. With Clarity gives you access to gemologists with decades of experience. They can offer guidance on jewelry, lab grown and natural diamonds, and how to create custom jewelry to meet your needs.

Picking loose diamonds spawns plenty of questions, so you can consult with diamond experts for answers to your questions. It’s easy to make an appointment with a diamond expert where you can select which diamonds you’d like to see–either in person at the With Clarity NYC offices or virtually. In a consultation appointment, you and a senior gemologist view your diamond selections, discuss its quality attributes (4 Cs), and ask any questions that you have.

The Fine Print

It’s important to compare company policies to protect your important purchase. Here’s a snapshot of both companies.

Returns Shipping Warranty Financing Resizing
With Clarity Free, insured returns within 30 days of receipt Free, insured shipping Lifetime warranty With Clarity Credit Card & Affirm One free resizing within 30 days of your purchase
Brilliance 30 day money back guarantee Free shipping Lifetime warranty Affirm One free resizing within 90 days of your purchase

Is With Clarity the Right Choice?

The founders of With Clarity, Anubh and Slisha, created a business based on their own complicated process of designing an engagement ring. They wanted to create a simpler, innovative way to custom make engagement rings, and With Clarity was born and has grown fast. Anubh and Slisha hoped to make jewelry buying transparent, convenient, and affordable (without outrageous markups).

With Clarity offers more than just engagement rings. You can find gemstone rings, earrings, anniversary bands, necklaces, pendants, and wedding bands (for men and women). Plus, you can customize each piece in terms of metal, gemstone, and cut to create your ideal piece of jewelry. The customization is part of the jewelry selection and not an extra cost.

With Clarity has experts that can answer questions about jewelry, diamonds, warranty policies, insurance, and returns. When purchasing fine jewelry, It’s helpful to have an accessible diamond expert via phone, chat or email when questions arise.

Shop Engagement Rings


  • Can you return a product purchased from With Clarity?

With Clarity accepts returns with purchase date.

  • Does With Clarity offer free shipping?

Yes, With Clarity offers free shipping on all orders.

  • Can I get loose diamonds from With Clarity?

Yes, you can purchase loose diamonds from With Clarity. Use With Clarity's loose diamond search tools to narrow your selection criteria for the perfect size, quality and price in order to find the perfect gemstone. All loose diamond purchases come with the original GIA diamond grading report (GIA certificate).

  • Where is With Clarity located?

With Clarity’s headquarters is located in New York, NY.