With Clarity vs. De Beers Forevermark

With Clarity vs. De Beers Forevermark

The number of online jewelry retailers is overwhelming! So it’s important to choose a reputable brand for important fine jewelry purchases. Two jewelry brands that you’ll see are With Clarity and DeBeers Forevermark. As we compared these two brands, we came to the conclusion that With Clarity is worth considering. Keep reading to learn more about these two brands.


About DeBeers Forevermark

De Beers selects diamonds for its De Beers Forevermark collection of responsibly-sourced diamonds. Each De Beers Forevermark diamond receives a unique De Beers Forevermark inscription, and they’re available at over 2000 jewelers locations worldwide. You’ll find several collections featuring the De Beers Forevermark diamonds.


About With Clarity


When Anubh and Slisha embarked on their own journey to purchase an engagement ring, they were left frustrated and realized that there was a need for a better engagement ring shopping experience. Their goal was to improve the ring-buying process using technology-enabled 3D-printing and customer-friendly online shopping with the same compassionate, helpful resources you have when you’re in-person shopping. The overall goal was to make the engagement buying process less stressful and more enjoyable.


High-Quality Jewelry at Budget-Friendly Prices


Shoppers appreciate With Clarity’s excellent jewelry quality and reasonable prices. Another aspect that shoppers consider is sourcing. Sourcing and grading diamonds are complicated processes, but With Clarity wants to make shopping for a diamond simpler and more transparent. They’ve done this by vetting each step in the process so you can shop confidently and get affordable prices by going straight to the diamond source. Cutting out middlemen saves you money and allows you to buy a high-quality diamond. They select trusted diamond cutters who use ethical practices to source and shape With Clarity diamonds.

With Clarity also offers lab grown and natural earth mined diamonds. Diamonds come with a GIA or IGI certification depending and an inspection by their in-house team of gemologists.

0.5 Ct. Natural Round Solitaire White Gold 0.7 Ct. Natural Round Solitaire White Gold 1 Ct. Natural Round Solitaire White Gold
With Clarity $734 $1,270 $3,000
De Beers Forevermark $3,400 $5,500 $9,600


Try on Your Ring at Home


A popular program that With Clarity offers is the Home Preview. It allows you to try on two custom replica rings for three days from the comfort of your own home. It’s an innovative idea that bridges the gap between online and in-person shopping by allowing you to try on jewelry at home using replica rings. The replica rings look exactly like “real” With Clarity engagement rings, but instead of metal they’re made using a white metallic alloy and a round, one-carat diamond simulant. When you’re done deciding which ring you love, you simply mail the rings back.


Talk to Diamond Experts


Another way that With Clarity bridges the gap between online and in-person shopping is to provide an accessible diamond expert for questions. Make an appointment with a diamond expert to ask questions and select which diamonds you’d like to see either in person in the With Clarity NYC offices or virtually. In this appointment, you and a senior gemologist can view diamonds, discuss their quality attributes (4 Cs), and ask all of your questions.


Customer Service that Cares


It’s normal to have questions when shopping for an engagement ring. When you’re shopping for a diamond and designing a ring, it’s common to have plenty of questions. Luckily, you can talk to With Clarity gemologists and jewelry experts who have decades of diamond experience. In addition, they have design consultants on staff who have custom jewelry expertise and can help answer questions about creating and finding jewelry to fit your needs.

A unique aspect of With Clarity is that they create custom jewelry and rings. You can contact them with either rough or detailed custom ring idea and get a quote back within a day with pricing info. Plus, the jewelry is made in the U.S. Their team of gemologists and design consultants works in-house in NYC to make all the custom designs.

Returns Shipping Warranty Financing Resizing
With Clarity Free, insured returns within 30 days of receipt Free, insured shipping Lifetime warranty With Clarity Credit Card and Affirm One free resizing within 30 days of your purchase
De Beers Forevermark Free returns within 30 days of receipt (as long as it’s unworn, in original packaging and shipping materials) Free shipping Lifetime warranty to for jewelry purchased directly through De Beers Forevermark Affirm Contact a De Beers Forevermark retailer to ask about resizing


Why Buy from With Clarity?


With Clarity’s owners created the company to provide a hassle-free experience as you shop and buy engagement rings. They focus on technology and compassion, and this combination makes purchasing an engagement ring less stressful. For example, using 3D rendering to create sample rings for their Home Preview try-ons so you get the ring you want.

It’s also helpful to read about other customer’s experiences and learn about the company’s commitment to sustainability. If you’d like to read reviews, they have thousands of 5-star reviews so you can hear about other shopper’s experiences. They’re also rated an A+ with the BBB.

With Clarity continues to grow fast because of their large inventory of earth-mined and lab-made diamonds in a variety of sizes and quality levels. Having a large inventory ensures you can find the perfect diamond for your loved one and your budget.

Finally, they have professionals on staff to answer your questions. Whether it’s a certified gemologist or a compassionate customer service associate, you’ll be able to get your questions answered. When you’re making an important purchase like an engagement ring, it’s essential that your questions get answered. It’s helpful to have an accessible diamond expert via phone, chat or email when questions come up. They’re also helpful for questions about warranties, insurance, and returns.



Does With Clarity sell loose diamonds?

Yes, With Clarity sells certified loose diamonds of varying sizes. If you have questions about diamonds, you can also chat with one of their diamond experts.

Does With Clarity sell certified real diamonds?

With Clarity carries GIA certified natural diamonds and IGI certified lab diamonds. GIA-certified diamonds provide a standard of consistency and transparency. GIA certification reports are thorough and provide all the relevant information required to assess a diamond. Each report has a unique identification number and all diamonds under 1 carat have a laser-inscribed GIA number on the girdle of the diamond in order to verify them.

What are the financing options at With Clarity?

You have the option to pay for your jewelry using the With Clarity credit card or through Affirm financing.