Is With Clarity Legit?

Is With Clarity Legit?

There are an overwhelming amount of options to buy fine jewelry online, which can lead to confusion. You want to ensure your jewelry is from a reputable company that will help you with such a meaningful purchase. You’ve likely seen With Clarity when shopping or researching fine jewelry. Keep reading for more about this company and what makes it legit.

With Clarity offers a lifetime warranty, financing options, insured shipping and free returns, which is innovative for an online fine jewelry company. Our lifetime warranty is for all jewelry, free of charge, and covers all wear and tear as well as complimentary cleaning, polishing, and replating as needed. We also provide complimentary replacement of stones under 0.10ct each that are broken or lost during everyday wear and tear. Fine jewelry can be an expensive purchase, so they offer financing through a Synchrony Credit Card or Affirm payments if you’d like a “buy now pay later” plan. Free, insured two-day shipping is included for all jewelry. Lastly, With Clarity offers free 30-day returns from the receipt of the jewelry purchase–no questions asked.

Home Preview

This option is one of the most popular items at With Clarity. It bridges the gap between online and in-person shopping by allowing you to try on jewelry at home via Replica Rings without an extra charge–it’s 100% free and helps customers shop with confidence. You receive up to two rings to try on for three days. These replica rings look exactly like real With Clarity engagement rings, and are made of a white metallic alloy and round one carat diamond simulant. When you’re done, simply mail the rings back.

Diamond Ethics

Many people are concerned about the source of diamonds and the ethical aspect of purchasing diamonds. With Clarity offers both earth-mined and lab-diamonds, and we’re committed to the highest level of ethical responsibility. We understand that the diamond you purchase is a symbol of love and commitment. For this reason, we ensure that every diamond offered is not tainted by conflict or human rights abuses. We work to enforce the strictest standards set forth by the Kimberley Process and United Nations Resolutions. We’re proud that the distribution of jewelry, from mine to market, adheres with all international laws and human rights policies. With supplier relationships that span generations, they have transparency into the operations and sourcing of our suppliers. Lastly, we only work with reputable suppliers who value conflict-free sourcing and ethical business practices.

Consultation with Diamond Experts

There’s a lot of information to absorb when shopping for fine jewelry–especially engagement rings. It’s helpful to browse online but have a diamond expert in case you have questions, so With Clarity offers both in-person or virtual shopping appointments. You browse diamonds, select a couple you’d like to see either virtually or in person (if you’re near NYC), and set up your appointment. You can ask questions and find the perfect diamond.

With Clarity Jewelry Options

When you think of With Clarity, you likely think of engagement rings, but they also have loose diamonds, wedding rings, gemstone rings, and other fine jewelry.

Engagement Rings

You have plenty of engagement ring options, from crafting your own ring, selecting a preset version, and customizing a ring based on your sketch or image. From a solitaire setting to a more elaborate engagement ring, With Clarity has you covered.

  • Craft a Ring (3 step building process): Choose your setting, then your diamond, and complete your ring to create the perfect ring for your special someone.
  • Preset Rings: With Clarity preset rings are crafted with care with the perfect blend of design and diamond sparkle. Simply customize for ring size and engraving and have the perfect ring ready for your proposal in a few days. It’s a guaranteed yes.
  • Custom rings: With Clarity expert designers and gemologists blend art, science and technology to bring you the perfect engagement ring. They take any sketch, image, or sample and bring it to life with 3D computer models, 3D printed wax renders, and eco-friendly gold and platinum metals.

Loose Diamonds

Another option you have is to choose between a natural diamond or a lab diamond. Both are available in a variety of cuts. With Clarity round brilliant stones continue to be the most popular cut. However you can find plenty of fancy shaped natural and lab-grown options if you’re looking for an oval, cushion, pear, marquise, emerald, or another cut.

Wedding Rings

With Clarity has wedding rings for both men and women. We have plenty of options if you want a metal band, anniversary band or a diamond band for your engagement ring. With Clarity offers perfectly paired wedding bands with our signature engagement ring designs, so each wedding band is a perfect match.

Gemstone Rings

In addition to diamonds, With Clarity allows customization of gemstone rings. Popular choices include ruby, aquamarine, amethyst, blue sapphire, moissanite, topaz, peridot, and black diamond. It’s helpful to browse online so you can see what the ring looks like with the customization options you select.

Fine Jewelry

If you aren’t in need of a ring currently, then you can browse With Clarity’s earrings, necklaces, pendants, and bracelets. Here are some of the options they have in a variety of metals (rose, yellow, and white gold as well as platinum):

  • Diamond heart pendants
  • Hoop earrings
  • Tennis bracelets
  • Drop earrings
  • Bangle bracelets


  • Is With Clarity a real company? Yes, it’s a real company that has grown over the past 9 years. With Clarity was founded in 2013 by a husband-and-wife team who were looking for a more personal ring-buying experience online.
  • Where is With Clarity located? With Clarity is located in New York, NY.
  • Are all diamonds available for viewing in person/virtually? You can schedule a virtual or in-person consultation with one of With Clarity’s diamond experts to assist you in choosing the perfect lab diamond.
  • Is With Clarity a reliable brand? Yes, it’s a reliable brand. With Clarity strives to be different and innovative in the way people shop for jewelry now and in the future. You can see our positive reviews from customers around the world featured online.